Occasionally annoying but usually insightful pundit Kevin Drum points us to an article in the LA Times by Steven Levy on the glories of the iPod. It’s an excerpt from Levy’s book The Perfect Thing. Now The Girls know this about me already–particularly Lindsey–but I will never get an iPod and there are several reasons why. This was actually a comment from the Kevin Drum post that I edited and enlarged a bit.
1) Apple Product. I can build a computer (it takes me forever and I’m not very good at it but…) and that means that Apple’s emphasis on design is irrelevant to me. I like my compatability and the logical sense I find in PCs. Thus I am biased against Apple to begin with but the real issue is this: like many agnostic or atheists I know, I have been witnessed a few too many times by Mac evangelists and now I have a knee-jerk resistance to Apple.
2) It’s an eggshell player. I drop my mp3 player (Sony’s Walkman) regularly, it’s got some scratches and dents in it after just 5 months. I mostly listen to it while jogging and that means its going to take a pounding in my shirt pocket or shorts pocket or wherever. I am totally honest when I say that if I had an iPod it would crumble to dust inside two weeks with the abuse I put my mp3 player through.
3) The wheel. In most versions of the iPod they use the wheel panel. To me this is completely counter intuitive and despite using it off and on for 4 years, I still cannot get used to it. My fingers and my mind are not made for the wheel. (As a matter of fact Apple OS’s frustrate me to know end with the way their buttons are, same problem!) The Sony Walkman has a twist know left for forward, right for back, pull out and it switches playlists. Very simple at least for me.
4) Batteries. My Sony walkman can run on full volume on the battery for something like 40-50 hours. Say I listen to it about 12-15 hours a week. I only need to charge it every 3-4 and even just plugging it into the computer to add another song to it gives it another few minutes of power.
5) No advantages. The iPod can of course be used as a portable data transfer device, but so can my Sony Walkman. My walkman has 512 MB which while not in the iPod’s upperange models, was a nice buy at about $70 and it serves my needs just fine. For anything else I’ll use USB or CDs or DVDs.
6) I hate the shuffle concept. When I load music onto an mp3 player, because I am jogging or walking somewhere, I need to distract myself. I am a very visual person. If I listen to the radio and hear a song, I’m not thinking about the lyrics very often. Usually I’m getting images in my head that are personal and important to me.
That means the music I load onto my mp3 player and the order I put it in allows me to imagine a story (and indeed the story I imagined while jogging has now become a draft of a novel) and the shuffle breaks that narrative. I like the music I listen to when it’s more than the sum of its parts so the shuffle is something I rarely use except when I have the winamp open on my desktop.
So that’s why I’ll never get an iPod. It’s not a bad device though it is fragile and expensive, but it was not designed for me.
Posted by samoflange 
Posted by samoflange
Posted by samoflange