So many of you have no doubt heard of the Omaha mall shooting. In the case it looks like the shooter was suffering from chronic depression and had just lost his job and been dumped by his girlfriend so it seems like he just decided to go out in a blaze of glory. I am only a couple hours away from Omaha here in Des Moines, less maybe from that mall so I suppose I could have gone over there to report directly for the blog but that would be a bit much even for me.
Anyhow, the point of this is that there are already some people (at Instapundit) arguing that if the mall patrons had been allowed to carry guns, things would have turned out better for all concerned. They cite in their defense a paper by Mary Rosh John Lott. Well that pretty much ends their argument right there but let’s throw up a counterpoint anyway.
According to them if patrons at the mall, while someone was shooting up the place, had drawn their guns and tried to attack the perpetrator everything would have been better. According to the paper, more guns means safety. So let’s assume that everyone in the mall of legal age and proper mental temperament has a handgun.
It’s a sudden situation. If you’re not right there, you don’t know who is shooting or at what. In such a situation it’s pretty easy to conjure a scenario where several gun-toting patriots, running to the scene start shooting at each other thinking the other person is the initial shooter leading to what I can only term a confused gun battle. As stray shots and chaos ripple outward from the shoot out, more and more people (with concealed handguns) rush into the combat zone and see people shooting at each other, and then pick sides or form a third side and try to shoot at everyone. Eventually as news of this battle spreads to the authorities, the police descend on them all with larger guns to force the peace resulting in potentially more mayhem.
This does not seem to me to be conducive in reducing casualties and ending the ordeal faster, but your mileage may vary.
Posted by samoflange
Posted by samoflange
Posted by samoflange